Skepticism: The New Religion

by Roy Stemman, (defunct), Oct 3, 2010
originally published in the Winter 2011 ATransC NewsJournal

Those of us who have received evidence that convinces us we will continue to exist, in some form, beyond death know that it can be a life-changing discovery. And most of us feel that this world–humanity as a whole–would be a better place if more people had knowledge of the evidence for survival after death and the opportunity to explore the evidence and the implications for themselves.

arthur_findlaySo it is hardly surprising that so many comments on my blog, Paranormal Review [No longer in use.] in recent weeks have expressed dismay over the decision by the Spiritualists’ National Union (SNU) [whose headquarters is at the Arthur Findlay College, Stansted, Essex, pictured above] to shut down Psychic News, a newspaper dedicated to promoting that evidence globally for almost eighty years.

Thanks to a Spiritualist charity, Psychic News has been reborn and is now published as a monthly magazine, sold on newsstands in the UK and globally on subscription, and its readership is increasing. See:

Though its readership has been declining in recent years, it has been responsible for introducing many people to the scientific evidence for an afterlife as well as Spiritualism’s philosophy. Its demise has left a gaping void and it is tremendously frustrating that those responsible for the decision are not answering questions about the real reasons for closing it, or their failure to come up with a rescue plan.

Contrast this lack of communication from Spiritualism’s largest UK organization with the activities of the skeptics–people who are on a mission to dismiss all evidence for paranormal phenomena and belief in an afterlife.

They are growing in numbers. Indeed, it seems to me at times as if skepticism has become a new religion. Their meetings take place at top venues around the world and their speakers’ skeptical assertions are lapped up with zealous enthusiasm by the delegates.

They even have their own Messiah–James Randi–a bearded prophet of rationalism whose appearance on stage at these events is usually greeted with a reception akin to worship. In the October news and updates email from the James Randi Educational Foundation, a not-for-profit organization, “social critic and magician” Randi says:

“For those of you who have supported the JREF since our inception in 1996, and even for those folks who are new to our coterie, there are a plenitude of reasons to be delighted.

“For instance, the JREF plans in the short term to enter the realm of digital publishing with skeptical titles poised for release on the iPad and iPhone, Kindle, and other digital schemes. We are increasing our video content on

“We have also launched a new grants for educators program and our regional workshops are a reality with St Louis, Chicago and Louisville already on record as the first of many such planned skeptical assemblages. We also recently awarded four new academic scholarships.”

The JREF is not alone. Another non-profit organization, the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry (CSI), publishers of Skeptical Inquirer announced two days ago that it wants to recruit a full-time communications director to handle press relations and publicity. Experience in public relations and/or journalism is required, of course, and applicants must be “familiar with the organization’s mission and demonstrate a commitment to humanism and skepticism.” Salary will be based on experience.

The CSI is an associate of the Center for Inquiry (CFI) which was established in 1991 and has expanded rapidly since then, moving into a new 20,000 sq foot headquarters in Amherst, New York (pictured), in 1995, to which it added a 15,600 sq ft research wing five years ago. With its mission “to oppose and supplant the mythological narratives of the past and the dogmas of the present” it has had considerable success in placing skeptics on national TV and radio programs.

“Literally hundreds of guests have been placed on thousands of programs,” says its website. “This includes all of the major networks – CBS, ABC, NBC, Fox, PBS – and virtually all of the cable companies – CNN, CNBC, MSNBC, C SPAN – as well as National Public Radio, AP Radio, etc.” The CFI maintains a Council for Media Integrity and “a rapid-response network to try to monitor programming and fight for balance in the media.”

So, what’s the difference between the SNU and the skeptical organizations–apart from the blindingly obvious fact that they champion very different philosophies? It’s clearly all about communication: telling the world what you are doing and even appointing professional people to do so on your behalf.

Whilst the skeptics are busy coming up with titles that can be read on iPads and Kindles, the SNU has killed off Spiritualism’s only independent, weekly newspaper and fired its staff.

For the record, I know that the SNU and its churches, ministers, mediums and healers do a tremendous amount of good in presenting evidence for spirit communication and promoting spirit-inspired philosophy. But it needs to be shouting that information from the rooftops. It has to explore ways of publicizing its activities (and those of similar organizations) through every avenue available.

The SNU website assures us that it “promotes knowledge of the religion, philosophy and science of Spiritualism” and that it “unites Spiritualists throughout the world and supports 340 Spiritualist societies and churches.” It also holds over 1,500 meetings a week across the UK–far more, I’m sure, than the rapidly-expanding skeptics groups in the US and Europe.

That’s all well and good, but in the battle for minds it seems to me that the skeptics have the upper hand right now. Their skepticism is even influencing the treatment of spiritual and paranormal stories by the supposedly objective media, due to a concerted campaign on their part. As a result, many newspaper and magazine articles I read now refer to Spiritualism in the past tense–as a religion that thrived in the 19th and 20th centuries, but is now virtually dead and buried.

We know that’s not true. But closing down Spiritualism’s unique weekly record will simply reinforce that view around the globe. It’s time for the SNU and all Spiritualist organizations to speak up!

[Editor: The skeptical organizations also have a substantial influence on how universities are funded and how the government grants your money for research. See Why Has There Not Been More Study of the Paranormal? at


Leave a Comment